, toronto, 2012.
Purpose: Isolated neck recurrence occurs in about 5–7% of patients after radical treatment of head and neck cancer. Limited information is available on the clinical outcome of such patients due to lack of randomized clinical trials. In addition, controversy still exists on the ideal technique of neck dissection required. This retrospective study is discussing the different options of salvage neck dissections for patients with isolated neck recurrence and its effectiveness on controlling disease progression.
Methods: At the National Cancer Institute, University of Cairo, Egypt, we identified 27 patients underwent salvage neck dissection for neck recurrence diagnosed between 2002 and 2011. We reviewed their medical records and retrieved their treatment history, pathologic and clinical characteristics, type of neck dissection, technique of reconstruction and outcome were analyzed.
Results: A total of 27 patients underwent salvage neck dissection for regional neck failure after their primary treatment. The primary treatment was surgery in 4 cases, combined with other modality in 15 cases, radiotherapy in 2 cases and combined with chemotherapy in 6 cases. The median time elapsed after primary treatment to diagnosis of cervical nodal recurrence was13 months. Nodal recurrences occurred on the ipsilateral (22), contralateral (4), and bilateral sides (3). The primary tumor sites included oral cavity (6), oropharynx (3), larynx and hypopharynx (6) and the rest of cases were in thyroid, salivary gland, eye, nasopharynx and one case of unknown origin. Types of neck dissection included RND (9), extended RND (9), MRND (7) and SND (4). Seventeen cases were staged N2 at the time of recurrence, 3 cases at N1 and 7 cases at N3. Five cases needed reconstructive surgery in the form of pectoralis myocutaneous flap or deltopectoral flap. One patient died postoperatively from pneumonia. Complications included wound infection (7), chylous fistula (2) and seroma in one case. Post operative adjuvant treatment was chemo radiation in 9, radiation in 4, radioactive iodine in 3, and chemotherapy in one patient. Ten patients developed recurrences after surgery. The recurrence was loco regional in 5, regional in 2, local in 2 cases and one patient developed lung metastasis. Disease free survival ranged from 4 to 18 months, seventeen were alive and free of disease at the last time of follow up, while 4 patients were alive with regional recurrence. Loco regional recurrence was the main cause of death accounting for 66% of cases.
Conclusion: Patients with resectable isolated neck recurrence following comprehensive neck management should be offered salvage neck dissection as it offers the best chance of cure. However, every effort should be made to make sure that that the primary site is controlled.